FTC Health Breach Notification Rule
16 C.F.R. Part 318; 42 U.S.C. § 17937Health Breach Notification Rule
In force since September 24, 2009
Who it applies to
- Vendors of personal health records that are NOT HIPAA covered entities or business associates
- Health apps, wearables, symptom checkers and similar connected devices that draw identifiable health information from multiple sources
- PHR-related entities and third-party service providers to them
Consumer rights
- Access / know, not granted
- Correction, not granted
- Deletion / erasure, not granted
- Portability, not granted
- Opt out of sale / sharing, not granted
- Opt out of targeted advertising, not granted
- Opt out of profiling, not granted
- Limit sensitive data use, not granted
- Human review of automated decisions, not granted
- Non-discrimination, not granted
- Appeal a refusal, not granted
- Private right of action, not granted
Obligations
- Consent model
- Opt-in
- Universal opt-out signal
- Not required
- Risk assessments
- Not required
- Data protection officer
- Not required
- Records of processing
- Not required
- Processor contract
- Required
- Right to cure
- None: enforcement may follow immediately
- Data broker registration
- Not required
Breach notification
- To individuals
- Without unreasonable delay and no later than 60 calendar days after discovery
- To the regulator
- To the FTC within 60 days of discovery for breaches affecting 500 or more individuals; for smaller breaches, in an annual log filed within 60 days of the end of the calendar year
- What triggers it
- A breach of security, which since the 2024 rule expressly INCLUDES an unauthorised disclosure such as sharing health data with an advertising network, not only a hack or a theft
Penalties
- Headline
- Civil penalties per violation per day under the FTC Act, which have reached tens of millions of dollars in settlements with health apps
- Private right of action
- No, enforcement is by the regulator only
- Notes
- THIS IS THE RULE THAT CATCHES WHAT HIPAA CANNOT, AND ITS 2024 EXPANSION IS THE POINT. A breach of security here does not require an intruder. An app that sent its users' health information to an advertising platform disclosed it without authorisation, and that is a reportable breach on a sixty-day clock. The clock and the thresholds deliberately mirror HIPAA's, so the two regimes read alike and apply to strictly different hands.
Exemptions
Entities
- HIPAA covered entities and business associates, which report to HHS instead; the two rules are mutually exclusive by design
Data
- Information that is not identifiable health information
- Records drawn from a single source with no consumer-managed aggregation
Amendment history
July 29, 2024
2024 Final Rule
Confirmed that health apps and similar technologies are covered, defined a breach of security to include an unauthorised DISCLOSURE and not only a data theft, and modernised the notice content and delivery.
Sources
- PrimaryRegulation16 C.F.R. Part 318, Health Breach Notification Rule
- PrimaryStatute42 U.S.C. § 17937, temporary breach notification for vendors of personal health records
- OfficialRegulatorFTC, Health Breach Notification Rule guidance