FTC Health Breach Notification Rule

16 C.F.R. Part 318; 42 U.S.C. § 17937

Health Breach Notification Rule

In force since September 24, 2009

Who it applies to

  • Vendors of personal health records that are NOT HIPAA covered entities or business associates
  • Health apps, wearables, symptom checkers and similar connected devices that draw identifiable health information from multiple sources
  • PHR-related entities and third-party service providers to them

Consumer rights

  • Access / know, not granted
  • Correction, not granted
  • Deletion / erasure, not granted
  • Portability, not granted
  • Opt out of sale / sharing, not granted
  • Opt out of targeted advertising, not granted
  • Opt out of profiling, not granted
  • Limit sensitive data use, not granted
  • Human review of automated decisions, not granted
  • Non-discrimination, not granted
  • Appeal a refusal, not granted
  • Private right of action, not granted

Obligations

Consent model
Opt-in
Universal opt-out signal
Not required
Risk assessments
Not required
Data protection officer
Not required
Records of processing
Not required
Processor contract
Required
Right to cure
None: enforcement may follow immediately
Data broker registration
Not required

Breach notification

To individuals
Without unreasonable delay and no later than 60 calendar days after discovery
To the regulator
To the FTC within 60 days of discovery for breaches affecting 500 or more individuals; for smaller breaches, in an annual log filed within 60 days of the end of the calendar year
What triggers it
A breach of security, which since the 2024 rule expressly INCLUDES an unauthorised disclosure such as sharing health data with an advertising network, not only a hack or a theft

Penalties

Headline
Civil penalties per violation per day under the FTC Act, which have reached tens of millions of dollars in settlements with health apps
Private right of action
No, enforcement is by the regulator only
Notes
THIS IS THE RULE THAT CATCHES WHAT HIPAA CANNOT, AND ITS 2024 EXPANSION IS THE POINT. A breach of security here does not require an intruder. An app that sent its users' health information to an advertising platform disclosed it without authorisation, and that is a reportable breach on a sixty-day clock. The clock and the thresholds deliberately mirror HIPAA's, so the two regimes read alike and apply to strictly different hands.

Exemptions

Entities

  • HIPAA covered entities and business associates, which report to HHS instead; the two rules are mutually exclusive by design

Data

  • Information that is not identifiable health information
  • Records drawn from a single source with no consumer-managed aggregation

Amendment history

  1. July 29, 2024

    2024 Final Rule

    Confirmed that health apps and similar technologies are covered, defined a breach of security to include an unauthorised DISCLOSURE and not only a data theft, and modernised the notice content and delivery.

Sources

Timeline

todayFTC Health Breach Notification Rule in forceSeptember 24, 20092024 Final RuleJuly 29, 2024