CIRCIA
6 U.S.C. §§ 681–681gCyber Incident Reporting for Critical Infrastructure Act of 2022
In force since March 15, 2022
Three different questions get filed under this heading and they have different answers: who must secure a system, who must report an incident, and who may be prosecuted for causing one. This page grades jurisdictions by what the law actually compels, not by whether it has a cybersecurity statute.
The distinction that matters most: a criminal prohibition is not a security obligation. The CFAA punishes the intruder and asks nothing of the defender. CIRCIA, NIS2 and the Cyber Resilience Act compel the defender to act, on a clock, before anyone has been charged with anything. Treating an anti-hacking statute as evidence of a security regime is the most common error in this area.
No US state map here, and for the same reason as trademark and copyright: these duties attach through sectors, not geography. The genuinely state-level layer, written security programmes and breach notification, is on the privacy map, where it already lives, rather than being counted twice.
What separates these is not only the length but what starts them. A clock running from “awareness” behaves very differently from one running from a materiality determination, and the 24-hour ransom clocks run from the payment itself rather than from discovery of the incident.
| Rule | Who | Clock | Runs from |
|---|---|---|---|
| CIRCIA (ransom payment) | US critical infrastructure | 24 hours | the payment being made |
| EU Cyber Resilience Act | Makers of products with digital elements | 24 hours | awareness of active exploitation |
| NIS2 (early warning) | EU essential & important entities | 24 hours | awareness of a significant incident |
| NYDFS Part 500 (extortion) | NY-licensed financial services | 24 hours | an extortion payment |
| CIRCIA (incident) | US critical infrastructure | 72 hours | reasonable belief an incident occurred |
| NIS2 (notification) | EU essential & important entities | 72 hours | awareness |
| NYDFS Part 500 (event) | NY-licensed financial services | 72 hours | determining an event is reportable |
| UK NIS Regulations | Operators of essential services | 72 hours | awareness |
| SEC Item 1.05 | SEC-registered public companies | 4 business days | determining the incident is material |
| FISMA (major incident) | US federal agencies | 7 days | identification |
No general federal security statute for the private sector. Duties attach by sector, critical infrastructure under CIRCIA, listed companies under the SEC rules, health under HIPAA, finance under the GLBA, while the CFAA punishes intrusion without requiring anyone to defend against it.
Cyber Incident Reporting for Critical Infrastructure Act of 2022
In force since March 15, 2022
SEC rules on cybersecurity risk management, strategy, governance and incident disclosure
In force since December 18, 2023
Federal Information Security Modernization Act of 2014
In force since December 18, 2014
Computer Fraud and Abuse Act
In force since October 16, 1986
US security duties come from sector regulation rather than from a general statute, and NYDFS Part 500 is the most detailed of them. The broader state layer, written security programmes and breach notification, sits on the privacy map rather than being duplicated here.
New York State Department of Financial Services Cybersecurity Requirements for Financial Services Companies
In force since March 1, 2017
The most demanding regime in force. NIS2 compels risk management and 24-hour early warning across eighteen sectors, DORA extends it to finance and directly supervises critical ICT providers, and the Cyber Resilience Act is the first law anywhere to regulate the security of software as a product.
Directive on measures for a high common level of cybersecurity across the Union
In force since October 18, 2024
Regulation on digital operational resilience for the financial sector
In force since January 17, 2025
Regulation on horizontal cybersecurity requirements for products with digital elements
In force since December 10, 2024
Retained the NIS Regulations after Brexit and is diverging from NIS2 rather than tracking it. Supervision is split across sector-specific competent authorities rather than held by one regulator.
Network and Information Systems Regulations 2018
In force since May 10, 2018