FTC Act § 5, health data

15 U.S.C. § 45(a)

Federal Trade Commission Act, Section 5: unfair or deceptive acts or practices, as applied to health information

In force since September 26, 1914

Who it applies to

  • Any company in commerce, with no health-care nexus required and no covered-entity status needed
  • Reaches the privacy promise itself: a policy, a app-store listing, an in-app screen, or a reassurance given in support chat
  • Reaches unfairness independently of any promise, where a practice causes substantial injury consumers could not reasonably avoid

Consumer rights

  • Access / know, not granted
  • Correction, not granted
  • Deletion / erasure, not granted
  • Portability, not granted
  • Opt out of sale / sharing, not granted
  • Opt out of targeted advertising, not granted
  • Opt out of profiling, not granted
  • Limit sensitive data use, not granted
  • Human review of automated decisions, not granted
  • Non-discrimination, not granted
  • Appeal a refusal, not granted
  • Private right of action, not granted

Obligations

Consent model
Mixed
Universal opt-out signal
Not required
Risk assessments
Not required
Data protection officer
Not required
Records of processing
Not required
Processor contract
Not required
Right to cure
None: enforcement may follow immediately
Data broker registration
Not required

Breach notification

To individuals
No notification duty of its own; the FTC's Health Breach Notification Rule supplies the 60-day clock for the entities it covers
To the regulator
Not required by this law
What triggers it
Not a breach regime. The violation is the unfair or deceptive practice, which may be a disclosure that was never a security failure at all

Penalties

Headline
Injunctive relief, consumer redress, and civil penalties per violation per day once an order or rule is in play; recent health-data settlements have run from the low millions to tens of millions of dollars
Private right of action
No, enforcement is by the regulator only
Notes
THE THEORY THAT ACTUALLY GETS USED, AND IT NEEDS NO BREACH. A health app that promised never to share user data and then sent it to advertising platforms through an analytics tag has made a deceptive statement, and the FTC can act on that without proving anyone broke in. The orders are what sting: beyond money they have required deletion of the data, bans on sharing health information for advertising at all, and years of reporting. Note the structural gap -- Section 5 does not reach most genuine non-profits, so a non-profit health service can sit outside HIPAA and outside this too.

Exemptions

Entities

  • Banks, savings and loans, federal credit unions and common carriers, which answer to their own regulators
  • Most genuine non-profits, which is a real gap: a non-profit health app can be outside both HIPAA and Section 5

Data

  • None by category. Section 5 does not define protected data, which is exactly why it reaches the health data the specific rules miss

Amendment history

  1. March 21, 1938

    Wheeler-Lea Amendment

    Added 'unfair or deceptive acts or practices' to the original prohibition on unfair methods of competition, which is the clause every health-data case is brought under.

Sources

Timeline

todayFTC Act § 5, health data in forceSeptember 26, 1914Wheeler-Lea AmendmentMarch 21, 1938