FTC Act § 5, health data
15 U.S.C. § 45(a)Federal Trade Commission Act, Section 5: unfair or deceptive acts or practices, as applied to health information
In force since September 26, 1914
Who it applies to
- Any company in commerce, with no health-care nexus required and no covered-entity status needed
- Reaches the privacy promise itself: a policy, a app-store listing, an in-app screen, or a reassurance given in support chat
- Reaches unfairness independently of any promise, where a practice causes substantial injury consumers could not reasonably avoid
Consumer rights
- Access / know, not granted
- Correction, not granted
- Deletion / erasure, not granted
- Portability, not granted
- Opt out of sale / sharing, not granted
- Opt out of targeted advertising, not granted
- Opt out of profiling, not granted
- Limit sensitive data use, not granted
- Human review of automated decisions, not granted
- Non-discrimination, not granted
- Appeal a refusal, not granted
- Private right of action, not granted
Obligations
- Consent model
- Mixed
- Universal opt-out signal
- Not required
- Risk assessments
- Not required
- Data protection officer
- Not required
- Records of processing
- Not required
- Processor contract
- Not required
- Right to cure
- None: enforcement may follow immediately
- Data broker registration
- Not required
Breach notification
- To individuals
- No notification duty of its own; the FTC's Health Breach Notification Rule supplies the 60-day clock for the entities it covers
- To the regulator
- Not required by this law
- What triggers it
- Not a breach regime. The violation is the unfair or deceptive practice, which may be a disclosure that was never a security failure at all
Penalties
- Headline
- Injunctive relief, consumer redress, and civil penalties per violation per day once an order or rule is in play; recent health-data settlements have run from the low millions to tens of millions of dollars
- Private right of action
- No, enforcement is by the regulator only
- Notes
- THE THEORY THAT ACTUALLY GETS USED, AND IT NEEDS NO BREACH. A health app that promised never to share user data and then sent it to advertising platforms through an analytics tag has made a deceptive statement, and the FTC can act on that without proving anyone broke in. The orders are what sting: beyond money they have required deletion of the data, bans on sharing health information for advertising at all, and years of reporting. Note the structural gap -- Section 5 does not reach most genuine non-profits, so a non-profit health service can sit outside HIPAA and outside this too.
Exemptions
Entities
- Banks, savings and loans, federal credit unions and common carriers, which answer to their own regulators
- Most genuine non-profits, which is a real gap: a non-profit health app can be outside both HIPAA and Section 5
Data
- None by category. Section 5 does not define protected data, which is exactly why it reaches the health data the specific rules miss
Amendment history
March 21, 1938
Wheeler-Lea Amendment
Added 'unfair or deceptive acts or practices' to the original prohibition on unfair methods of competition, which is the clause every health-data case is brought under.
Sources
- PrimaryStatute15 U.S.C. § 45, unfair methods of competition and unfair or deceptive acts
- OfficialEnforcementFTC, cases and proceedings
- OfficialRegulatorFTC, privacy and security business guidance